Delicious Easter jello with home made pudding, marshmallows and cheddar cheese


Delicious Easter jello with home made pudding, marshmallows and cheddar cheese

One of my most favorite deserts is my Grandma’s jello salad.  She made up this recipe and it is a family favorite.

I use different variations of this Jello salad, but the same technique Grandma taught me.  The home made pudding is out of this world. It is very easy to make.

When my husband first saw this jello salad, he wasn’t sure what to think.  He told me he didn’t think the cheese was such a good idea, he didn’t think he’d like it.  His mind was quickly changed once he took a taste.  Don’t write this off because you think the cheese will not be good, it is wonderful.

I found these cute, rabbit shaped, marshmallows and decided to use them since it is Easter.  They are hidden a little in the cheese, but it’s still a cute presentation. 

This recipe makes a lot of Jello Salad. I cut it in half and I have fun with the combinations of jello and fruit. I also use the flavored marshmallows to mix things up a bit. Kids love this, and adults do too!

My Grandma makes this a lot, and she always adds different kinds of fruit with the pineapples. Her favorite type of fruit to add are bananas. I’m allergic to bananas! I went to her house and she told me she made her jello salad. I cut myself a piece then put it right back in the pan. I went back into the living room with no jello. She was just about to ask me why, when her eyes got all big and she said BANANAS! A few weeks later she made the jello again. This time she didn’t add banana’s and was happy to tell me that. I was so glad I could have a slice of her jello salad.  I get a slice and there were some odd looking fruit pieces mixed in with the pineapple, just to be sure I asked what they were, Mango. I’m allergic to mango too. So, I had to learn how to make it myself, or I’d never get any I could eat! Ha Ha.

The first recipe is Grandma’s actual Jello Salad.  The ingredients I used for the salad pictured are listed below.  Feel free to experiment with flavor combinations. 

Grandma’s Jello Salad:

1 regular package Lemon Jello

1 regular package Orange Jello

 can crushed pineapple

1 bag mini marshmallows

Orange Juice

2 TB. sugar

3 TB. flour

1 egg, beaten

1/3 cup lemon juice

1/2 pint whipping cream (or 8oz. Cool Whip)

Grated cheddar cheese

Prepare Jello according to package

Drain pineapple and reserve the juice

Add pineapple to jello

Pour into glass dish

Cover with mini marshmallows and refrigerate to gel

Add orange juice to pineapple juice to make 1 cup

Pour into sauce pan

Add sugar, flour, and beaten egg

Cook over medium heat until pudding like, stir constantly

Remove from heat and allow to cool at room temperature, stirring occasionally

Once room temp., refrigerate until ready to add to Jello salad

Put whipping cream in a bowl and add lemon juice

Fold in the pudding mixture, whip together (if using whipped topping, then mix into pudding mixture)

Put on top of marshmallows then grate cheese on top

Refrigerate until ready to serve

Easter Jello Pudding ingredients:

Raspberry jello

Bunny shaped Marshmallows

Fruit cocktail drained, reserve the juice to use for the pudding


About Hey Paw

I am a novice cook. I don't have a lot of experience but I come from a family full of wonderful cooks. Guess I got the recessive, non-chef gene. I thought it would be fun to post my trials and errors in a blog. Hopefully this will help others learn from my mistakes and I can get constructive advice from other cooks out there.

4 responses »

    • Hi! I believe Grandma used Tidbits. Unfortunately she passed away this past January, so I can’t confirm. I always use the tidbits. Please let me know if you tired it and how you liked it!!!

    • Hello again. 🙂 Yes the orginial recipe is pretty big so the 9X13 should be good. Honestly I don’t pay attention to pan sizes. I basically have “small”, “medium” and “large”. I use a “large” pan for the orginial recipe and the medium pan when I cut it in half. lol My Mom and sister are so accurate about everything, me not so much. This recipe is my most popular recipe. On my other blog, it’s the most searched recipe. I hope you love it as much as we do!

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s